Fresh look at Top 5 backs

[Clamp]

http://www.nfl.com/videos?videoId=09000d5d806a7d2e

Interesting video. I like this guy's reasoning. i would need to watch a little more game film on all of them before i would be completely sold on ALL of the points but he makes good points about all of those backs. Interesting that he doesnt rate any of them as top 10 backs and McFadden as a mid-first.

From what i saw of his tapes i does seem that McFadden is a little over rated. id rather have Mendenhal.

[aj.]

That's the Mayock piece that was on NFL-N last night. I was talking about this somewhere else. Compelling case for Mendenhall over McFadden.

[headsplint]

That's the Mayock piece that was on NFL-N last night. I was talking about this somewhere else. Compelling case for Mendenhall over McFadden.

I agree, everytime I see a highlight reel of Mendenhall, the more I want that guy at 18 if at all possible he fell that far.

[Wolf123]

The only problem I had with his analysis is when he said stewart only has one speed. If he only has one speed how is it that he's able to run away from defenders so easy.

[El Tejano]

I believe Stewart has the best vision out of all of them though. To me Mcfadden runs too high and Mendenhall doesn't have blocking down yet in college.